American History
The
Treaty
of Versailles
*The Great War ended
at 11:11 AM on 11 November, 1918, but creating a peace treaty was much
more complicated.
*Woodrow Wilson wanted a ‘peace without victory,’ and had a plan for a
post-war world, safe for democracy and without any more war. His
plan involved Fourteen Points.
*Wilson demanded an end to secret treaties, a reduction in weaponry for
all nations, eventual freedom for Europe’s colonies, self-determination
for ethnic groups in Europe, and a new way for the nations of the world
to work together to preserve peace, stability, and freedom: a
League of Nations.
*Wilson went to Europe to promote his plan, become the first president
to visit Europe while in office, and was greeted like a king when he
arrived in France. Streets were named for him, crowds cheered him
wherever he went, and people across Europe expected a new age of peace
and freedom.
*Wilson made mistakes, however. He brought no Republicans with
him, which made the Republicans at home, led by Henry Cabot Lodge,
resent his work and try to turn Americans against him.
Furthermore, he misunderstood the nature of European politics and
overestimated the power of his convictions.
*The major European leaders at the conference in Versailles were David
Lloyd George (UK), Georges Clemenceau (France), and Vittorio Orlando
(Italy). They had little interest in freedom or justice,
particularly for Germany. France in particular wanted
revenge. Among other things, Germany was forced to pay
reparations for the entire war (impoverishing the country), and, worst
of all, accept the humiliating ‘war guilt clause.’ Wilson
protested, but was told he had to accept it, or there might be no
League of Nations.
*Europe’s leaders were willing to allow some of Germany and
Austria-Hungary’s eastern lands their independence and encouraged the
republics that formed after the old emperors were overthrown.
Many new nations were created, although some, such as Yugoslavia and
Czechoslovakia, were made up of several ethnic groups joined under one
government, and many of the Yugoslavians did not appreciate this.
However, where the Central Powers bordered the Allies, the Allies
planned to take their land. France re-took Alsace-Lorraine and
Italy took over South Tyrol. Wilson protested against this, but
was told he had to accept it, or there might be no League of Nations.
*The Ottoman Empire completely collapsed into Turkey and many different
Arab (and a few other) states, which were placed under the temporary
control of Britain and France. The new country of Iraq was
created out of three different Ottoman Provinces (Basra, Baghdad, and
Mosul) which contained different ethnic and religious groups, who ended
up dominated by the Sunni Arabs. Wilson protested against this,
but was told he had to accept it, or there might be no League of
Nations.
*Europe also did not want to give up its foreign colonies (except that
Germany had to give all of its colonies to Britain, France, and
Japan). Wilson protested against this Although not as much as he
did against other compromises), but was told he had to accept it, or
there might be no League of Nations.
*Wilson did get the League of Nations, but when he got home and
campaigned across the country for the acceptance of the Treaty of
Versailles, it was rejected by the Senate, largely due to Republican
opposition, particularly because the League of Nations required all its
members to help defend any member state that was attacked or otherwise
in danger of losing its independence. Many Americans feared this
would get America involved in another European War. After all
Wilson’s work and compromises to create the League of Nations, American
never joined (which was one reason the League ended up being weak and
ineffective).
*World War I was devastating to all the countries involved in it.
Most of the major countries involved lost over 3% of their entire
population. Just as the war was ending, the world suffered
another deadly tragedy, known as the Spanish Flu (a strain of H1N1)
(so-called because Spanish newspapers gave it the first major coverage,
even though the first known cases appeared in the US and then in other
European countries). It lasted from 1918 to 1919.
*It is estimated that a third of the world’s population, on all
inhabited continents (and even remote Pacific Islands) was infected,
and between 50 million and 100 million people died—more than died in
World War I (about 15 million). Over one in four Americans was
infected; over half a million died (far more than the 53,000 Americans
killed in battle in World War I or the 63,000 who died outside of
combat).
*After all this death, Americans were tired of involvement in world
affairs. Not only did they reject the Treaty of Versailles
(although another treaty was later signed with Germany), but in 1920
America (including many women voters, thanks to the XIX Amendment)
voted for Warren G. Harding, who promised Americans a Return to
Normalcy.
*Nonetheless, American could not avoid all involvement with the rest of
the world. Many of the Allied countries had borrowed money from
the US during the war (and Germany owed the US some reparations, which
will be fully paid off in 2010), and the US had to have some interest
in making sure these debts were paid.
*World War I changed the world. New nations were created, a
generation of young men was nearly wiped out, and the survivors felt
lost in the world around them. In many countries, the generation
that survived World War I was known as the Lost Generation, which had a
reputation for being cynical, short-sighted, and unreligious (as
religious belief declined in countries who had all thought they were
fighting with God on their side). In Germany in particular, the
burden of war reparation, the loss of territory, and especially the
humiliation of the War Guilt Clause led to bitterness, resentment, and
a desire to find scapegoats and new leaders who would restore the glory
of the German Empire.