War and
American Society
The Seminole Wars
*In the 1700s and 1800s, as European and American settlers pushed into
the Deep South, they fought with and displaced many native peoples,
many of whom fled to Florida. Among these were the Yamasee and
the Lower Creek (mostly living in Georgia), who sought to escape
Europeans, the Cherokee, and the Upper Creek (mostly living in
Alabama), but also some Choctaw and many others. Eventually these
tribes (who had similar languages) and many runaway slaves merged into
one large group that the Spanish called cimarrons (runaways, or wild
men), which the Indians came to pronounce Seminole.
*The War of 1812 and the Creek War forced more Creek to move to
Florida, where the British (who had encouraged them to fight the US
during the War of 1812) gave them protection at a fort in the Florida
Panhandle that local whites called the Negro Fort because so many of
their slaves ran away to join the Seminole there. When the
British left Spanish Florida after the War of 1812, they left the Negro
Fort in the hands of runaway slaves and black veterans of the British
Corps of Colonial Marines.
*The black and Indian leaders of the fort encouraged more slaves to run
away and join them, and even raided local plantations for supplies and
to free more slaves. Eventually this was too much for the local
planters, who called on the nation’s greatest hero, Andrew
Jackson. He built a fort called Fort Scott in Georgia that was
deliberately re-supplied by ships that passed very near the Negro
Fort. On 17 July, 1816, the Negro Fort fired on an American
flotilla and killed four Americans. Ten days later, Jackson sent
the Army (with Creek allies) and the Navy to attack the fort. Hot
shot from one of the gunboats hit the powder magazine, destroying the
fort and killing 250-270 of 300-330 occupants. Jackson’s Creek
allies were allowed to scavenge from what was left, and took home over
2,500 muskets. This began the First Seminole War (1816-1818).
*This increased hatred between local whites and Indians, each of whom
made many small raids on the other, mostly to steal livestock, although
white attacks often killed Indians as well. Finally, the Seminole
went too far, killing a woman named Mrs Garrett and her two children
(one 3 years old and the other 2 months old) in February, 1817.
Not long afterwards another ship sailing to Fort Scott was attacked,
and many of the people on board (including women, children, and sick
soldiers) were killed in what was called the Fort Scott Massacre.
This was too much for the Untied States, who also blamed the British
for this, saying that they encouraged (or at least did not restrain)
Seminole attacks on the United States.
*In March of 1818, Andrew Jackson invaded Florida with 800 regulars,
1,000 Tennessee militiamen, 1,000 Georgia militiamen, and some Creek
allies. On 6 April, 1816 he seized the Spanish fort at St
Mark’s. He soon arrested Alexander George Arbuthnot, a Scottish
trader accused of selling guns to the Indians, and Robert Ambrister, an
ex-Royal Marine who admitted to being a British agent to the
Indians. Both were sentenced to death, although Arbuthnot
insisted his trade was legal—he was hanged from the yardarm of his own
ship (Ambrister was executed by a firing squad). Jackson also
hanged two Indian leaders who sought refuge on an American ship.
*Jackson then marched on Pensacola, and occupied it on 27 May,
1818. The Spanish surrendered the fort outside of town (to which
they had retreated) the next day. Jackson then went home, leaving
one of his officers in charge of Pensacola.
*The Spanish and the British were outraged, but neither wanted a war
with the United States at the time (the US were too important to
British trade, and Spain was busy fighting most of its American
colonies’ efforts at independence). Some members of Congress
wanted to censure Jackson, but he was so widely-regarded as a hero that
he was later made governor of Florida instead (although he only stayed
for three months).
*In 1819, John Quincy Adams and Luis de Onís Gonzalez Vara
negotiated the Adams-Onis treaty, ratified by Spain in 1820 and the US
in 1821. This ceded Florida to the United States in exchange for
American payment of Spanish debts to Americans up to $5 million.
It also fixed the border between New Spain and the United States, and
when Mexico got its independence, it mostly agreed to the same border.
*The new US territory of Florida still had trouble with the
Seminole. In the Treaty of Moultrie Creek in 1823, some Seminole
agreed to move onto a large reservation in central Florida in exchange
for US protection, money, farming tools, and education. However,
many of them were reluctant to move, even after the United States began
building forts to demonstrate that they had better do as they were
told. Furthermore, Seminole still tended to steal cattle from
Florida farmers, who often responded with violence.
*The 1830 Indian Removal Act was meant to deal with this by removing
the Indians beyond the Mississippi River. In the 1832 Treaty of
Payne’s Landing, seven Seminole chiefs sent to Indian Territory agreed
to move there by 1834, but when they got home, they said they never
signed the treaty, or were forced to do so.
*Many other chiefs had never agreed to move at all. Micanopy, a
high chief of the Seminole said that he had not, and the young war
leader Osceola said that to move would be to let the white man make him
a slave. He said, ‘The white man shall not make me black. I will
make the white man red with blood; and then blacken him in the sun and
rain... and the buzzard live upon his flesh.’
*Soon certain Seminole leaders declared that any Seminole who sold his
land or cattle to a white man was a traitor who would be
executed. Osceola soon killed a Seminole chief named Charley
Emathla for doing just that.
*On 28 December, 1835, a party of soldiers led by Major Francis Dade
left Fort Brooke (near Tampa) to bring supplies to Fort King (near
modern Ocala), were ambushed by a Seminole war party led by Micanopy,
and all but 3 of 110 men were killed (and one of those 3 was killed on
the way back to Fort Brooke). The Dade Massacre began the Second
Seminole War (1835-1842).
*Winfield Scott, hero of the War of 1812 and the Black Hawk War was
placed in charge of US operations against the Seminole. The first
attacks were led, however, by General Edmund Gaines, who soon found
himself cut off by the Seminole and forced to wait for rescue by
General Scott.
*For years the US Army and the Seminole hunted each other through the
swamps of Florida, the army burning Seminole towns and the Seminole
attacking the small forts that Army built in Florida and any
settlements they could. Sometimes Seminoles would surrender, then
change their mind, or pretend to surrender and then attack soldiers
caught off their guard.
*Eventually Scott left Florida to handle Cherokee Removal (which he
disapproved of but was ordered to oversee) and then to negotiate with
Canada over the border between Maine and New Brunswick, and Thomas
Jesup was placed in command. He managed to capture of kill a
number of Seminole, but often did so by pretending to offer a truce for
negotiations, then capturing Seminole who came to speak with him.
This was how Osceola was captured in 1837. Osceola died of
malaria in Fort Moultrie in Charleston, South Carolina three months
later.
*In open battle, Jesup’s forces were less successful. On 25
December, 1837, a detachment of his army under Zachary Taylor attacked
Seminole led by Billy Bowlegs in the Battle of Lake Okeechobee.
The Seminole had cut the swamp grass ahead of time to make a clear
field of fire in an area of three-foot water and mud where horses would
be useless. Taylor thought that a direct charge against them
would force them back, but his militia ran when their commander was
killed, and the Seminole charged after them, killing and scalping
many. The regular army units that stood to face them lost almost
all of their officers, who were specifically targeted.
*Still, Taylor’s men eventually pushed the Seminole back, and despite
taking far worse casualties than the Seminole (who they outnumbered 800
to 400), it was considered a victory for Taylor.
*As the Seminole retreated, Jesup pursued them and caught up with them
on the banks of the Loxahatchee River. There he and 1,500
American soldiers surrounded and defeated 300 Seminole on 24 January,
1838, in the last large battle of the Second Seminole War.
*Jesup was replaced by Zachary Taylor, known as Old Rough and Ready,
and the closest thing the war had to a hero, although he later
requested a transfer out of Florida himself. He, and subsequent
commanders, tried to create as many forts and roads as they could in
Florida to make it easier to patrol, and tried to hunt down the
Seminole in the swamps. They tried to hunt the Seminole with
bloodhounds, but the water washed away the Indians’ scent.
*Eventually, William Worth decided it was no longer worth fighting the
Seminole if they would stay in the Everglades, and an informal end to
the Second Seminole War was reached. It was the longest war
America fought between the Revolution and the Vietnam War.
*Despite the peace that followed the Second Seminole War (sometimes
just called THE Seminole War), the leaders of Florida (which became a
state in 1845) wanted all the Seminole removed, and the Secretary of
War, Jefferson Davis, agreed. He sent more soldiers to forts
around the Seminole reservation and placed a trade embargo on them and
threatened to use force if they did not leave Florida. Soon, the
Seminole attacked, beginning the Third Seminole War.
*On 20 December, 1855, Billy Bowlegs led an attack on an army patrol
near Fort Meyers. His 40 men killed and scalped four men and
killed all the mules. Soon more soldiers and civilians were
killed.
*For the next few years, the Army and the Florida militia failed to
stop the Seminole, although they were able to reduce their attacks
some, particularly once they began using long metal ‘alligator boats’
that did not leak or rot to hunt for Seminole in the swamps.
Eventually, though, many Seminole were paid to move to Indian Territory
and the rest were allowed to remain in the Everglades. Today
their descendents refer to themselves as the Unconquered People.
*Although most Seminole live in Oklahoma today, there is still a large
population in Florida, where they grow tobacco, operate casinos, and
attract tourists. They have also made an agreement with Florida
State University allowing them to use their tribal name for their
sports teams.